Thank you for visiting The Islander Newspaper Online.

We are currently updating our website to provide you better service and function.
If you would like to access the new site, please, click here: The Islander Newspaper

Sorry for any inconvenience. Our new site and service will resume shortly.

Web Master

The Award Winning & Best News on Anna Maria Island, FL Since 1992

"The Award Winning & Best News on Anna Maria Island, FL Since 1992"

Sunday, Nov, 23, 2014
Florida Press Assn. Award-Winning Web Site
Home Latest News Weather Sports Real Estate Classifieds Island Guide Islander Store

 SECTIONS

 • 

Main News

 • 

Classifieds

 • 

Opinions

 • 

Streetlife

 • 

Calendar

 • 

Fishing

 • 

Sports

 • 

Real Estate

 • 

Obituaries

 • 

Weather

 Features

 • 

Cortez Cook Off: The Results

 • 

Anna Maria Island Bridge FDOT replacement bridge

 • 

National Hurricane Center (Atlantic)

 • 

Advanced Search

 • 

I love AMI

 • 

Mystery Story

 • 

Fishing Laws

 Classifieds

 • 

Classifieds Page

 • 

Place An AD

 • 

Items for Sale

 • 

Garage Sale

 • 

Estate Sale

 • 

Announcments

 • 

Lost & Found

 • 

Pets

 • 

Transportation

 • 

Boats & Boating

 • 

Fishing

 • 

Kids 4 Hire

 • 

Help Wanted

 • 

Health Care

 • 

Services

 • 

Lawn & Garden

 • 

Landscaping

 • 

Home Improvement

 • 

Business Opportunities

 • 

Rentals

 • 

Real Estate

 Weather

 • 

Today's Forecast

 • 

10 Day Forecast

 • 

Today's Tides

 • 

Emergency e-mail

 • 

Storm Watch

 Archive

 • 

News Archive

 • 

2009 Top Notch Gallery

 • 

2008 Top Notch Gallery

 • 

2007 Top Notch Gallery

 • 

2006 Top Notch Gallery

 • 

2005 Top Notch Gallery

 • 

2004 Top Notch Gallery

 Useful Links

 • 

Island Links

 • 

i.wed

 • 

Islander Store

 • 

About this Site

 Contact Us

 • 

Islander Store

 • 

Subscribe

 • 

About Us

 • 

e-mail us

Story Tools

Date of Issue: March 17, 2005

Watkins variances quashed by judge

A circuit court judge has ruled that a series of variances granted last year by the Bradenton Beach Board of Adjustment "be quashed."

Circuit Court Judge Paul Logan ruled that, in addition to nullifying the setback and impervious surface variances granted by the board to Greg Watkins' property at 400 Bay Drive S. "It would behoove the City of Bradenton Beach Board of Adjustment to hold a hearing de novo on the applicant's application for variances, or to deny the requested variances."

De novo hearings are administrative proceedings where new evidence and testimony are admitted, not the review of previous testimony. In essence, the judge said the whole process should start over again.

Since work on the property has been completed pursuant to the board of adjustment decision to grant the variances, and prior to the court's ruling that the approval was illegal, it is not clear what action should be taken by Watkins.

Building Official Bob Welch said it would be up to the city commission to decide whether or not Watkins would be ordered to demolish the structures that are located within the setback areas.

"Mr. Watkins was issued several permits to construct walkways, stairs and porches based upon these variances," Welch wrote to city commissioners and members of the board of adjustment on Dec. 15. "These permits are now called into question. This matter needs to be reviewed by an attorney.

"The judge has indicated that the board of adjustment could rehear the issue," Welch continued. "If evidence can be found that a hardship exists, the variance could be granted and the permits made legal. If the variances are not reheard and granted, the work performed under the permits may have to be removed. Either way, the city needs to act upon this matter in the near future."

No date for any city commission or board of adjustment action has been set as of presstime.

Logan's decision was rendered Aug. 26. The matter was not brought to the attention of former City Attorney Alan Prather, Building Official Bob Welch, or even Watkins until last week.

Watkins' variance requests first came before the board of adjustment Feb. 20, 2002. Action was tabled to Feb. 27 due to a lack of a quorum.

On Feb. 27, then-Chairman John Burns announced that his term of office had expired as of Feb. 23. Without the city commission's affirmative vote to continue his term, Burns said he was uncomfortable with voting on the Watkins variances and the board again tabled the matter.

Watkins' requests finally came before the board of adjustment April 25. At that meeting, Burns was replaced as chair by Ken Lohn. That meeting was continued until May 30, when a decision was finally reached granting Watkins' requests.

Watkins has three small cottages on his property at 400 Bay Drive S. which are non-conforming as to setbacks. He has elevated the structures on pilings and have undergone extensive remodeling.

Watkins, who is also a member of the board of adjustment but recused himself from voting on his requests, said he had received nine building permits allowing him to proceed with the work.

Board members agreed to rear- and front-yard setbacks for staircases, and agreed to allow him to have a variance for impervious surfaces on the property with some stipulations.

Members of the board present during the proceedings included Lohn, Burns, Anna O'Brien and Jan Vosburgh.

O'Brien later was elected to the city commission.

Neighbor David Stott was critical of the work done by Watkins, and filed suit against the project in May 2002. The last action on the matter -- prior to Logan's ruling -- was Dec. 10, 2002, when Stott's attorney Adele Kurtz said she would be unavailable during the previous holidays (Christmas and New Year's).

In his decision, Logan said the standard of review on the matter rested in whether the "administrative tribunal accorded procedural due process, observed the essential requirements of law, and based the administrative findings on competent substantial evidence."

Logan said the board of adjustment "failed to adhere to their ... land development codes [which state that a non-conforming structure may be enlarged only if it does not increase the extent of non-conformity].

"A review of the record shows there was testimony at the April 25, 2002, hearing wherein Burns specifically stated that, by granting the variances, the board has approved 'a project to increase non-conformities where the opportunity to decrease them was there before and there still is.' No other testimony or evidence was adduced before the board to the contrary. Such testimony or lack thereof, evidences a departure from the land development code, and consequently, a departure from the essential requirements of law."

Logan said the final administrative order by the board for Watkins' variances "is devoid of any competent substantial evidence." He also said the board "failed to make factual findings to support their decision that the applicant's property endured a legal hardship, whether the legal hardship was self-created, and whether the hardship warranted the granting of a variance."

Logan also raised issues of conflict of interest and impropriety.

"The court also reminds the board that the state standards of conduct apply to members of ... boards who are appointed by ... commissions to serve in an advisory capacity," he wrote. "Further, it is incumbent upon the board to avoid the appearance of impropriety. Impartial decision making is a basic component of minimum due process in an administrative proceeding.

"The record indicates that preceding the requests for variances, the chairman of the board of adjustment, Kenneth Lohn, sold the property at issue to the applicant, Greg Watkins, who is a fellow board member with the chairman," Logan continued. "There is no evidence on the record that the chairman abstained from voting or disclosed his interest or indirect interest in the property at issue. This may portray a conflict of interest as well as the appearance of impropriety."

Have your say:

No comments for this page. Feel free to be the first

Username:

Contact:

(email or url)

Subject:

Your View:

Please enter the security code below:

security  

Get breaking news

Follow the Islander on TwitterBecome a fan of The Islander on Facebook

Sign up to receive breaking news alerts via e-mail. We'll send you a notice when the news and classifieds appear online every week, before the print edition hits the streets.

Click here for Gulf oil spill updates related to Anna Maria Island.

Historic Anna Maria City Pier Plank Walk

Put your name, your message, your memorial on the Historic Anna Maria City Pier prior to the Pier Centennial Celebration! And join the fun!

CLICK HERE for Stoltzfus e-mails and related court documents.


FREE Island
Vacation Guide:
get it here

Cortez Cookoff

Click here for 2010 Cortez Cookoff Winner and recipes

To advertise here, please
visit our rates page
or contact us at:
sales@islander.org
Phone: (941) 778-7978
Fax: (941) 778-9392

Back to top of Page

Home | Weather | Real Estate | Classifieds | Archives | Contact | Island Links
Islander Store | Subscribe About this site | Classifieds Page | Place an Ad
For Sale | Garage Sales | Announcements | Lost & Found | Pets | Transportation
Boats & Boating | Fishing | Kids for Hire | Help Wanted | Health Care | Services
Lawn & Garden | Landscaping | Home Improvement | Business Opportunities | Rentals | Real Estate

Our Privacy and Copyright Statements © 1992 - 2009, The Islander