Environmentalists challenge Aqua developers’ mitigation plan

thumb image
Joe McClash, former Manatee County commissioner, fishes in Sarasota Bay while looking toward the shoreline proposed for use as a mitigation bank adjacent to the future Aqua by the Bay development. Islander Photo: Kathy Prucnell

Next up in a dispute over a pristine stretch of Sarasota Bay coastline is a Dec. 5 hearing that pits two nonprofits and a former Manatee County commissioner against developers and the Florida Department of Environmental Protection.

Environmentalists Joe McClash, Suncoast Waterkeeper Inc., and the Florida Institute for Saltwater Heritage are challenging the DEP’s “intent to issue” a permit to operate a mitigation bank to Long Bar Pointe LLLP, controlled by developers Carlos Beruff and Larry Lieberman.

The DEP issued its conditional approval in December 2016 and the environmentalists followed in February with a challenge.

Suncoast Waterkeeper’s mission is to protect and restore the waters of Sarasota and Manatee counties through enforcement and advocacy.

FISH is a group of some 180 members dedicated to preserving the Cortez maritime community.

Proposed for 261 acres of mostly submerged lands south and east of Cortez, the bank would form part of a 529-acre, mixed-use development. Manatee County commissioners approved Aqua by the Bay in October for 2,894 homes and 78,000 square feet of commercial space.

The DEP permit — if upheld by a judge appointed by the state Department of Administrative Hearings — would allow the developers to sell 18.01 credits: 7.38 for seagrass-dominated submerged bottomlands, 0.23 for salt marsh, 7.07 for mangrove swamps, 0.68 for trimmed mangrove hedge and 2.65 for coastal freshwater marsh.

At a price of $100,000-$200,000 a credit, the operators could profit from the sale of credits to developers — even the Beruff-Lieberman entity — as a trade-off for wetland destruction in Manatee, Sarasota and Charlotte counties.

Suncoast Waterkeeper’s Stu Smith contends a permitted bank would pay Beruff to remove invasive plants already required by Manatee County rules, install a dozen “potentially harmful,” “useless at best” seagrass warning signs and enable “harmful” mangrove trimming.

“The bank would generate millions of dollars for Beruff and set terrible precedents and do almost nothing for the environment,” Smith said in a Nov. 19 news release.

In addition to the DEP permit, the bank operator will need approvals from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to sell mitigation credits to developers whose plans destroy federal wetlands.

The federal regulator denied permit applications from the Beruff-Lieberman partnership this year on May 5, and also in September 2016.

Corps public information officer Nakeir Nobles said Nov. 22 the agency has not received a subsequent mitigation permit application from the Beruff-Lieberman entity.

According to DEP communications director Lauren Engel, the agency stands by its intent to issue the permit and won’t comment on pending litigation.

Pete Logan, president of Medallion Home, Beruff’s company, wrote in a Nov. 22 email that Beruff and Lieberman “don’t traditionally comment on pending legal matters.”

Administrative Law Judge D.R. Alexander will hear the case at 9:30 a.m. Tuesday, Dec. 5, at the Southwest Florida Water Management District office, 6750 Fruitville Road, Sarasota.

One thought on “Environmentalists challenge Aqua developers’ mitigation plan

  1. John Young

    How would the DEP’s Long Bar Pointe LLLP permit to operate a mitigation bank not be a license to kill and destroy already established wetlands that are already sustaining endangered species there and protecting coastline from storm surges etc? Wouldn’t the first step be for Long Bar to first establish it’s proposed wetlands development and bring the wetland’s up to speed in terms of species diversity and coastland protection before proposing a trade with those with Manatee, Sarasota and Charlotte county shoreline being stripped of their protective etc wetlands? How are those stripped of their wetlands to be compensated?

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *