Animal advocate continues push for no-kill community

Holmes Beach animal advocate Lisa Williams is pushing forward with her call to Manatee County government to become a no-kill community.

Appalled by the large numbers of shelter animals put to death rather than adopted into homes, Williams, who works at The Islander, first voiced her opinion on the newspaper’s Jan. 19 editorial page.

She called for “powerful, fast change in Manatee County” and for officials to give more than lip service to the issue.

After pointing out that Manatee County Animal Services killed 140 animals in December while complimenting the 10 animals it adopted from a downtown Bradenton storefront, it was Williams who received lip service in a flurry of responses.

Holmes Beach resident Jean Peelen, serving on the county animal services advisory board, wrote that while the number of animals euthanized is horrible, there are more facts that didn’t appear in the guest editorial that people should know.

Peelen wrote, “In December, 235 dogs and 137 cats were picked up by animal services wandering the streets. Sixty-nine dogs and six cats were returned to owners. Forty-eight dogs and 30 cats were transferred to rescue groups. Fifty-seven dogs and 17 cats were adopted.

“Animal services is a small group of under-funded people who are doing what they see to be their best with the deluge of dogs and cats being abandoned by owners,” continued Peelen. “They didn’t create the deluge and they probably cannot, alone, create the solution.”

Peelen added that she’s “all for creating a real no-kill policy in Manatee County.”

Denise Deisier, director of the Humane Society of Manatee County, has long been pushing the county to become a no-kill community and also is willing to work with Williams to lobby for change.

Williams said Gulfshore Animal League also has offered its support.

However, Williams said she met with individuals calling her out for having a “Pollyanna complex” and lacking background, or prior involvement from which to judge the system.

Sue Kolze, the vice president of the Animal Network who has been involved in pet rescues in the community for more than 12 years, also took Williams to task.

Williams maintains adoption fees MCAS charges are prohibitive. She said nonprofit rescue groups are charged $15 to take charge of an animal scheduled to die. Individuals are charged $60 to adopt a cat and $80 to adopt a dog.

Williams believes adoptions should be free.

But Kolze countered that rescue organizations requested the animals be vaccinated, which led to the county commission approving a fee to cover that cost.

Kolze claimed in her e-mails that Manatee County currently abides by a “no-kill of adoptable animals” philosophy.

And, Kolze claimed, “Just because families are willing and wanting does not make them qualified adopters who will give the animals good homes with proper food and veterinary care.”

Kolze said “animals need more [people] who are involved in helping the rescue effort, rather than [people] who sit back and point fingers.”

However, Williams doesn’t see animal advocacy as a hobby. Having spent time working for PETA traveling the country and investigating animal cruelty, she said she intends to be part of the solution.

She said she is working toward setting programs in place that would support the success of a no-kill community.

So, when Kolze and the Animal Network challenged Williams to put up or shut up by adopting the next 10 animals set to be euthanized by MCAS, Williams didn’t hesitate to lead by example.

On Jan. 31, she picked up the cats and dogs and brought them home to stay with the greyhound-shepherd pooch she adopted in Mississippi while volunteering to help animals displaced after Hurricane Katrina.

The Animal Network paid the adoption fees and the pets were spayed or neutered, vaccinated and micro-chipped.

In two weeks, Williams, found foster family for one of the cats and Pumpkin, the 1 1/2-year-old pit bull mix featured in the Feb. 9 issue of The Islander, was adopted to a home in Ocala.

The “challenge” pets offered by Williams for adoption and an up-to-date list of pets held by animal services and scheduled for disposition — including kill dates – can be found on The Islander website.

Williams said Pumpkin, who was taken in by MCAS on Jan. 26, was scheduled to die Feb. 1 — only one week after intake.

Williams is distributing a “No-Kill Primer” to anyone interested in learning more about a no-kill community. She also is circulating a petition calling for the animal services to cease killing animals.

“Other communities have done it, and it is time for Manatee County to make the change,” she said.

Kolze also challenged Williams to name any community where taxpayers support a no-kill community.

Next week: More on Williams’ “challenge pets,” no-kill communities and local solutions.

Sign the petition

To sign Lisa William’s petition for a no-kill solution in Manatee County, go to, e-mail, or sign up on facebook at Make Manatee County No Kill.

For more information on adopting one of her “challenge” pets, call Williams at 941-345-2441 or e-mail

More from The Islander

5 thoughts on “Animal advocate continues push for no-kill community


    From: Sue Kolze, VP of Animal Network, Inc

    Re the Feb 16th issue of The Islander: Thanks to Lisa for helping these animals, and thanks to Bonner for running an article about the project. We’re hoping that Bonner & Lisa will use their power of the press to get people interested in raising sponsorship money and encouraging people to adopt & foster some of these animals that are being put to sleep at Animal Services. Note: Animal Services MUST take every animal that is picked up or turned in, and they have a limited number of cages. They do not have the flexibility of shelters and rescues to select which animals they take in. We hope that the caring public will step up and help, just as Lisa did.

    Please feel free to contact me if you have any questions about Animal Network’s effort for Manatee County to become a no-kill of adoptable animals community.

  2. CP

    I signed the petition and joined the Facebook group as well. How can I receive a copy of the “No Kill Primer”?

    Bravo to Lisa Williams {and everyone else} who speak for those that cannot speak for themselves!

    Until there are none, adopt one!

    Do not purchase animals from pet stores!

  3. j.sunderhaus

    It is not a good idea for the shelter not to charge for adoptions. $60.00 for a cat or $ 80. 00 is not a lot of money to pay for a dog. and if you cannot afford that chances are you will not be able to afford to feed and provide proper medical care for the dog or cat
    The shelter has to charge to help cover the care for the animals while they are in the shelter and pay the employees and all the expenses in keeping a facility for these animals to go if they are lost so they can find their family or are surrendered or dumped.

  4. Maureen McCormick

    I applaud Ms. Williams for her efforts, no organization should be offended or try to diminish what she is doing, It is strictly about the animals.
    No-Kill Rescue is very important, Spay and Neuter is another critical part of rescue and the third part of a balanced humane effort is to stop over-breeding by puppy millers and backyard breeders.
    A shelter tax needs to placed on any business or private breeder selling animals. That money needs to be set aside exclusively for the care of those animals once they end up abandoned, permitted to stray or turned in.
    Puppy mills, un-neutered pets and backyard breeders looking to make a few bucks out of the family pet are the largest contributors to the over-population of pets and that is where most of the shelter population originates. Making them pay heavily up front for the burden they cause later, not to mention the cruelty to animals, will act as a deterrent. Manatee County can and should lead the way in this effort.
    A great analogy is “Turn off the faucet before you start mopping up the floor” . Stop the overbreeding and and then you can focus on caring for those pets who need to be re-homed.

    Good Luck Lisa.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *