AM halts homebuilding, lower height limit planned

The past week was a roller coaster ride for Anna Maria commissioners and residents. Some longtime residents said it’s just the city getting back to its wild and crazy past.

On Jan. 24, commissioners approved a motion to enforce a minimum of 30-day stay for vacation homes, among other limits.

Following an uproar from those who own vacation homes, commissioners held an emergency meeting Jan. 29 and rescinded the restriction. At the same meeting, commissioners agreed to meet weekly until they find solutions to the myriad issues surrounding rentals and new construction in the city.

The first of the weekly meetings took place Jan. 31 and commissioners reached a consensus for an immediate administrative moratorium on new construction, while city attorney Jim Dye prepares an ordinance to enact a moratorium.

Commissioner Nancy Yetter was not at the meeting, but she had sent an email asking that moratorium discussion be delayed.

The commission’s action preempted her request.

Commissioners agreed that building permit applications already “in the pipeline” at city hall would not be affected by the moratorium.

After hearing numerous residents plead for a reduction from the present 37 feet to a 27-foot building height restriction, commissioners agreed, telling city planner Alan Garrett to prepare an ordinance reducing the limit for future permitting, essentially eliminating new three-story homes.

Mayor SueLynn was concerned that would be considered a “taking” of property rights and, with city attorney Jim Dye absent, asked Commissioner Chuck Webb, an attorney, for his opinion.

Webb said “each case is different” and it would be difficult to give an opinion on how a height restriction might affect someone. Essentially, he said, a private citizen would have to prove the height limit resulted in “a taking” of his or her property rights.

If current building permit applications stay in the pipeline and the city moves fast with a new height ordinance, Webb said it would halt future mega-homes, but he could not definitively say the city would never be sued.

“It’s a case-by-case basis,” he said.

Future homes could also be limited to a living area of 40 percent of the lot size, said Garrett, and commissioners agreed. For a 5,000-square-foot lot, that would provide 2,000 square feet of living area, Garrett noted.

“That’s big enough,” said Commissioner Gene Aubry, an architect.

One resident after another, including former Mayor Gary Deffenbaugh, spoke in favor of a 27-foot height limit.

Commission Chair John Quam agreed that changing the height limit is a good start to halting the influx of multi-bedroom vacation rentals.

“People have been coming here and building mega-homes, living in them for a year and then selling them,” he said. Those large houses were then turned into vacation rentals, attracting more than the usual number of guests to an accommodation, he said.

Commissioner Dale Woodland also was concerned with rowdy renters, who create noise and nuisance problems for city residents living adjacent to party houses.

“That’s what we’re trying to solve,” Quam said, but the issues are inter-related and not all can be solved at one meeting.

Woodland wanted the commission to establish a priority list of problems, and to direct code enforcement to immediately address them.

Quam, however, said that’s the mayor’s job. Commissioners can go directly to the mayor with complaints, he noted, adding SueLynn has been working with Sgt. Paul Davis, the new head of the Manatee County Sheriff’s Office-Anna Maria substation, to improve enforcement.

Webb said he was involved with Dye and the MCSO in establishing new guidelines for deputies to handle complaints.

He said deputies will respond to a complaint of loud noise or a rowdy party. If necessary, deputies will issue a citation and pass the violation to code enforcement.

Resident Mike Coleman, principal with Pine Avenue Restorations, including vacation rental properties, suggested property managers and owners should be liable for code citations.

Webb said many rental agencies, including those operated by Larry Chatt and Mike Brinson, are willing to work with the city, but a few are ignoring the policies established in November and adopted by Chatt, Brinson, the mayor and others.

The city might consider establishing a licensing ordinance to track vacation homes because, Webb said, renting a home is a commercial venture and the city can require businesses to obtain a license and have it posted in a conspicuous location on the property.

Code enforcement officers already have a database of almost 500 rental properties and corresponding owners and managers, but requiring a license for each vacation rental would provide names and contact information for owners of vacation rentals.

SueLynn said she would look at a license code for businesses and report back to the commission.

“But we need the public to help,” Webb said, and the mayor noted the new attitude of MCSO deputies toward nuisances.

Webb urged the public to call the MCSO number with complaints. The new policy will result in action by deputies and code enforcement officers. If a member of the public feels they were ignored in making a complaint, he urged them to come to city hall and make that known.

Other issues related to vacation rentals and new construction will be addressed at the next workshop, Quam said, at 6 p.m. Thursday, Feb. 7, at city hall, 10005 Gulf Drive, Anna Maria.

9 thoughts on “AM halts homebuilding, lower height limit planned

  1. Ben Hardin

    The island has been taken over by a group of over-regulating snobs who do not want to live on a vacation island. They have no regard for property rights. They will soon be sued, leaving a mess to clean up. Vacationers, second homeowners, and business owners will end up paying for their selfishness.

  2. Peter Rafano

    Having booked a week on the island this August, I’m now worried we’re going to turn up to find we don’t have a property we’re allowed to stay in.

    What is actually happening on the island?


    1. MIke

      Pete, you are fine. The city is going through growing pains and commissioners are trying to scare off future development. The sad part is residence only want noise complaints dealt with. Who would have known that dealing with noise complaints and issuing a citation to the perpetrators could be so hard!!

  3. LJM

    We presently own a very small house in Holmes Beach (800 sq ft), which we use as a vacation home on most weekends. We do not rent it out. We hope to retire to AMI one day to a larger home that will accomodate us and visits from our two kids and grand kids. Why should the city commission get to tell us that 2000 sq ft is big enough for our needs? We’ve always figured that, if we don’t find another house that we want, or if we are unable to sell our little cottage, we could always remodel our current house into something we could live in through retirement. These restrictions on height and square footage could very well squelch our plans. All these restrictions on the use of private property is very unsettling and is not the American way of doing things.

    1. becca

      It’s not always just about “You.” The majority want to keep the integrity of the old Island feel. It’s one of the last places left in Florida, at least the areas that haven’t been violated by these McMansion rentals, that still has the authentic island vibe. I agree w/the comment above about making it an Historic District thus protecting it from RUIN.

  4. mb

    Before lowering the height limit so drastically, someone should think about what the new homes will end up looking like. Anna Maria’s original cottages are quaint, but when you put a house like that on pilings 18 feet in the air, as would be required in areas seaward of the coastal construction control line, you will basically have a flat roofed box on stilts. This in no way resembles the Anna Maria vernacular, nor does it allow the design of a cracker style cottage. In addition, by restricting height, you will be forcing future construction to cover virtually all of the allowable square footage, reducing green space and planting area.

    If anna maria commissioners are concerned about the character of homes built in the future, they might be better served by adopting an ordinance that restricts existing homes from being demolished or being over expanded, thereby retaining homes in their present form. This can be done by either creating a historic district, or a design committee to review new construction and renovation.

    1. Colette Bryant

      This is the best idea I have heard since this issue started! I lived (rented) part of a duplex on 68& Gulf drive in the late ’90s & my family & I return allmost evry year for our vacation.My old duplex is now a beautiful renovated home that was not demolished and is a single home.The person who bought it did a wonderful job, just wish I still lived there!!.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *