You’re welcome to attend, but stay tuned for time, day and date.
A violation hearing before a city magistrate to determine the fate of a tree house in Holmes Beach is set for May 4 — but that date could be postponed.
The case of the beachfront structure at 103 29th St. also is up June 6 before a judge in 12th Circuit Court.
Opposing motions in court seek to answer the question of whether a citywide vote can be held on the fate of the elaborate tree house, built without permits, asking if it can be grandfathered into the city.
The tree house is located seaward of the erosion control line setback, where building is not allowed without state and city permits.
In the administrative case, Holmes Beach code enforcement officer JT Thomas delivered an amended notice April 21 to tree house owners Lynn Tran and Richard Hazen, stating the city intends to seek a fine for their failure to remove or relocate the tree house.
The notice reads: “The city has determined the final administrative order issued by the city of Holmes Beach Code Enforcement Board on July 31, 2013, has not been complied with and that the city will seek an order imposing a fine to obtain compliance.”
Tran said April 22 she sent an email requesting the city postpone the hearing 60 days.
The owners’ attorney, David Levin of Icard, Merrill, Cullis, Timm, Furen & Ginsburg of Sarasota, also sent a similar request to city officials.
If the city doesn’t grant a postponement, Tran said Levin may seek an injunction to stop the hearing.
The pending court case includes a request to halt enforcement of the prior code board order.
“Why don’t we wait until that gets resolved?” Tran asked.
In 2011, Tran and Hazen built the tree house in an Australian pine tree — measuring about 89 inches in diameter and 120-feet tall — with two elevated observation decks, four concrete pilings, removable windows and solar paneling — on the beachfront at 29th Street where they reside and operate Angelinos Sea Lodge, four weekly rental units.
Kelly Fernandez of Persson & Cohen, a law firm based in Lakewood Ranch, is assigned as the magistrate for the city’s tree house proceedings.
More than three years of litigation precedes the scheduled hearings, including the owners’ appeal of the July 2013 code board ruling, that ordered the owners to:
· Pay city fines and penalties due as a result of constructing and altering a structure without a building permit.
· Contact the city building department to remove all violations and, if the structure cannot be constructed according to code, obtain a demolition permit and remove the structure.
· Pay $4,271 for the city’s costs incurred in the case.
Another code board order set a fine of $100 a day for each day the structure remained out of compliance, but the 12th Circuit Court halted the fine in March 2014. It was vacated pending the appeal.
After the final decision not to review the appeal by the 2nd DCA, Jim Dye of Dye, Deitrich, Petruff & St. Paul of Bradenton, said the fines will be decided anew by the magistrate.
The special magistrate is empowered to levy fines of $250 per day for first-time violations or $500 for repeat violations for each day past the ordered compliance date.
Thomas delivered two notices to the owners April 20 and April 21.
The amended notice softened the wording in the original letter, instead asking the owners “to explain” why the property hasn’t come into compliance, Tran said.
Thomas said he expects the magistrate to try “to get closure on the case.”
To this solution, Tran said, “I’d love to be able to do that. Just sit down and talk about it.”
Thomas forwarded Tran’s postponement request April 22 to the magistrate, Dye, Holmes Beach Police Chief Bill Tokajer and building official Jim McGuinness.
At press time, the magistrate hearing was scheduled for 10 a.m. Wednesday, May 4, at city hall, 5801 Marina Drive.
The court hearing is set for 1:30 p.m. Monday, June 6, at the Manatee County Judicial Center, 1051 Manatee Ave. W., Bradenton.
What’s next?
Questions linger as to the fate of the beachfront tree house.
Will it stay? Or will it go?
A May 4 city hearing could result in up to $500 per day in fines for Angelinos Sea Lodge owners Lynn Tran and Richard Hazen for not removing the tree house.
A June 6 court hearing will address whether the tree house fate can be decided at the ballot box.
What appears certain is there is no end in sight.
A civil rights attorney representing the owners, Bruce Minnick of the Minnick Law Firm in Tallahassee, says the sticking point in a possible settlement might be what Holmes Beach wants to pay for bringing forward a code enforcement case it never should have brought.
In 2012, Tran and Hazen petitioned the Florida Department of Environmental Protection for an after-the-fact permit for the tree house.
But when the DEP required the city to sign off — and it wouldn’t — the owners defended the tree house at a city code board hearing, in the 12th Circuit Court and 2nd District Court of Appeal, and the city won.
According to the decision of 12th Circuit Judge Janette Dunnigan, the owners should have known better than to build the structure in 2011 based on the opinion of the then-city inspector, who purportedly told them a permit wasn’t required for a tree house.
Meanwhile, Minnick sent the city a letter in March giving officials time to investigate and resolve the dispute before “very costly” federal court litigation is undertaken.







