“Time is of the essence” was a repeated phrase April 18 at the Coalition of Barrier Island Elected Officials meeting in Bradenton Beach.
Ten city officials participated, including the mayors of Anna Maria, Bradenton Beach, Holmes Beach and Longboat Key.
The single-item agenda was targeted on surplus beach concession funds from Manatee County and whether Anna Maria and Bradenton Beach would support Holmes Beach’s request for $50,000 to implement a license plate recognition system on the island.
Members of the coalition agreed more research is needed before they support LPR funding.
Holmes Beach unanimously approved the item for concession funding in late March.
The concession fund, which has grown to more than $1 million — revenue from the two public beach concessions — is allocated by the county for capital improvement projects to benefit the public and must be recommended by the three island municipalities.
The three city commissions must approve any proposal before submittal to the county, but some officials and staff have expressed concerns the funds will be reallocated if the cities can’t finalize a request.
Anna Maria Mayor Dan Murphy said he is concerned with privacy issues and database security for the LPR cameras.
“It’s a scary thing to develop without knowing the implications,” Murphy said. “We need all the implications and a healthy discussion before we deploy eight cameras on the island tracking everyone’s moves.”
Murphy also shared concerns about the fallibility of the database.
“It’s not a matter of if it’s getting hacked, it’s a matter of when,” Murphy said.
Holmes Beach Police Chief Bill Tokajer, who previously made a presentation on LPR cameras, emphasized that data collection is only on offenders.
Longboat Key Mayor George Spoll said license cameras exist at both ends of the key and are about 40 percent effective at recording plates. He said they have helped LBK police pick up “undesirables.”
According to Tokajer, who proposed the LPR technology, Longboat Key is upgrading to the system he recommended.
Bradenton Beach Mayor John Chappie agreed more information is needed before taking the request to the county, and said he didn’t know before the meeting that the request is for eight cameras.
He said time is short to secure county funding and the camera proposal had not gone before his commission as part of the concession fund proposal.
Lynn Burnett, city engineer for the three island cities, said, “We know time is running out. We know that those monies have already been looked at by other departments of the county and they are already trying to figure out how to spend those monies in areas where they have shortfalls.”
Since the cities agreed on the project list exclusive of the $50,000 for the cameras, she suggested moving forward with everything else. Burnett said there would be other funding sources for the LPR system.
Holmes Beach Mayor Bob Johnson said since “time is of the essence,” the city could remove the $50,000 line item from its list and further research the system and funding options.
Bradenton Beach moves forward
During an April 19 city meeting, the Bradenton Beach commission unanimously approved the list of projects for the county concession fund request, minus the license plate recognition line item.
Holmes Beach chief weighs in
Tokajer sent a memo April 4 to Johnson, who sent it to the other two mayors, detailing the benefits of license plate recognition technology.
His memo said the LPR technology “is an intuitive and secure monitoring and recording tool that allows officers to crosscheck license plates for historical activity and statuses of stolen vehicles, as well as potentially locate vehicles which may have fled.”
In an April 19 interview with The Islander, Tokajer said he understands officials have questions, but the only data being collected is the picture of a license plate on the rear of a vehicle.
“The LPR is taking a picture of the license plate and car from the rear for identification purposes,” Tokajer said. “There is no privacy issue because there is no data. There is no info on who is in the car or who it is registered to.”
He said the only people who should be concerned are those who have committed crimes. “Regular citizens would not be tracked. We are not watching everyone’s comings and goings on the island. That’s far-fetched,” Tokajer said.
He said the system he is proposing — Vigilant Solutions — is used by the Manatee County Sheriff’s Office, as well as Sarasota, Charlotte and Pinellas counties.
He added that anyone who has recently driven onto Longboat Key or over the Sunshine Skyway Bridge has been subject to LPR technology.
“It just makes sense for us to monitor the comings and goings on our island because there are only three major entrances,” Tokajer said. “It will work out to be safer for all of our residents, visitors and business people.”







