AM beachfront homeowner digs in for battle after DEP ruling

Wendy Jordan isn’t giving up.

She’s fighting against what she calls a potentially devastating precedent that she says has resulted from a July 20 ruling by Shawn Hamilton, interim director of the Florida Department of Environmental Protection, upholding a June administrative court ruling that allows for building a structure seaward of the coastal construction control line.

The petitioner granted the DEP exception is Fedora Campbell, who owns the property at 105 Elm Ave. in Anna Maria.

The Campbell property is seaward of the house Wendy and Robert Jordan purchased April 1 for $4 million. Seaward of Campbell’s lot is another platted lot that the Jordans purchased as insurance to preserve their view and prevent future development.

However, the DEP and the administrative judge’s decision do not greenlight Campbell’s structure.

As it implies, the CCCL is a control line, not a “red line.”

Campbell must submit detailed plans for the structure size and footprint and other plans to the city building official that not only detail the structure, but also address emergency vehicle and utility access, issues complicated by the fact that Campbell’s property is seaward of the western terminus of Elm Avenue and the city’s right of way and beach access point.

As of July 23, Campbell had not submitted requests for building permits or plans, Anna Maria city clerk/treasurer LeAnne Addy told The Islander.

Because there are no plans to review, Addy said any comment on a permit for Campbell would be conjecture.

Meanwhile, a July 21 meeting between Jordan and Anna Maria Mayor Dan Murphy didn’t occur, with Jordan saying she left the island due to the effects of red tide. She said her request for a Zoom meeting was denied by the mayor.

Murphy said July 22 that he told Jordan she was welcome to meet in person when she felt well enough to return to the island, as he prefers to conduct meetings of such a serious nature in person.

Jordan said she would beat the drums and post signs directing people to her preserveAMI.com campaign until a literal line in the sand is drawn preventing construction seaward of the CCCL.

Something she said the DEP — “the very agency we pay to protect the environment” — should have ruled against Campbell when she first broached the subject of a building permit.

“The case will be pursued until we stop the threat,” Jordan wrote in a July 22 text to The Islander.

 

About the CCCL, ECL

The state CCCL Program regulates structures and activities that can cause beach erosion, destabilize dunes, damage upland properties, or interfere with public access — and helps protect sea turtle habitat and dune plants.

The state-established erosion control line, based on historical high tide data in Anna Maria, prohibits most construction seaward of the line. The ECL is the boundary between private upland property and submerged state-owned lands.