BB leaves Cortez in lurch

thumb image
Joe McClash entreats city leadership to join the lawsuit opposing DOT plans for a 65-foot-clearance fixed-span replacement for the Cortez drawbridge. Islander Photos: Kane Kaiman
Commissioner Jan Vosburgh, left, speaks in favor of joining the megabridge lawsuit Aug. 5. Commissioner Marilyn Maro, center, and Mayor John Chappie indicated they preferred to stay out of the suit.

The courtship has ended.

After a presentation, back-and-forth discussion and a recess to review a draft contract at a Bradenton Beach City Commission meeting Aug. 5, commissioners reached a 3-2 consensus to continue megabridge negotiations with the Florida Department of Transportation and declined to join the legal challenge facing the department’s decision to replace the 17-foot-clearance Cortez drawbridge with a 65-foot-clearance fixed-span structure in 2026-27.

Mayor John Chappie and Commissioners Ralph Cole and Marilyn Maro advocated for continuing discussions with the DOT and steering clear of the lawsuit.

Commissioners Jake Spooner and Jan Vosburgh favored joining the complainants in opposing the megabridge.

The Aug. 5 meeting began with a presentation from Joe McClash, a former Manatee County commissioner who spearheads a group of four people who lodged their initial complaint in federal court in March 2020 and began advocating for the construction of a 35-foot-clearance drawbridge to replace the aging Cortez Bridge.

During the presentation, McClash outlined two “major winning points” the anti-megabridge coalition has uncovered while reviewing the administrative record — a document detailing how the DOT came to its decision to build the high bridge.

According to McClash, the agency approved the bridge under outdated legal conditions and failed to abide by a federal rule requiring the department to choose the bridge alternative that would have the smallest impact on the surrounding floodplain.

McClash told the commission he located an attorney to represent his coalition and the city of Bradenton Beach at an upcoming mediation hearing Aug. 25 for about $25,000.

He summed up his presentation by asking the commission to join the suit and revert to the city’s original, March 18 commitment to allocate $15,000 toward legal fees.

“It would be my recommendation to spend the $15,000 and to help our neighbors, because it would be a nightmare to do it the other way,” Vosburgh said, following the presentation. “We don’t need that tall bridge and I think we would have the cooperation of almost everyone in Bradenton Beach to go ahead and do it.”

Chappie said the city needed more time to discuss the situation with the DOT and that he’d like to see the anti-megabridge coalition formally ask the Manatee County Board of Commissioners to weigh in on the issue.

He also indicated the city’s budget was tight and said, if pressured, he would vote against joining the suit.

Cole said he also would vote against joining the suit as an inappropriate use of taxpayer dollars.

Spooner initially voiced concerns about being drawn into a lawsuit where the city could incur more fees than expected. He suggested the draft contract be amended to allow the city to join the suit at no expense — at least through the mediation hearing.

Maro voiced concerns about Bradenton Beach bearing the brunt of the financial burden and prompted city attorney Ricinda Perry to review the draft contract.

After a brief recess, Perry highlighted what changes would need to be made to insulate Bradenton Beach from financial obligation.

Despite the possibility of joining the suit through the mediation hearing at no cost, Chappie and Cole did not change their positions and Maro tipped the balance.

Chappie, Cole and Spooner said they would privately donate to the lawsuit.

 

Negotiation autopsy

On March 18, commissioners unanimously voted to direct Perry to coordinate with outside counsel to join the suit and allocated $15,000 for legal fees.

In April, they reduced the allocation to $5,000 and Perry began settlement negotiations with the DOT.

At a July 1 commission meeting, Perry said the department rebuked the city’s proposal that the agency spend $4.8 million to underground utilities on streets inside and outside the scope of the megabridge project and build a sidewalk on a portion of Gulf Drive.

Perry said the agency asked her to scale back the requests and demonstrate how the construction of the high bridge would make them necessary.

Commissioners directed her to do so and continue her negotiations.

Based on public records obtained by The Islander, Perry had not communicated the scaled back requests to the DOT as of July 27.

Since the July 1 meeting, DOT District 1 Secretary L.K. Nandam and Perry have characterized the discussions between the city and the agency’s attorneys as something other than informal settlement negotiations.

“I wouldn’t call them settlement conversations,” Nandam said July 2. “I think this is part of any conversation that we have with our communities on what enhancements they would like to see within the scope of the project.”

“There are NO negotiations … this is a joint effort to help the community,” Perry said in an Aug. 6 text message to The Islander.

However, Perry has repeatedly characterized the discussions as negotiations in the past, most recently at the July 1 commission meeting.

“I want to be very careful, because we’re in negotiations, understanding that the reason for the negotiations is (the DOT) did not want to see the city of Bradenton Beach become a party to the lawsuit. That is the appeal of us working together. To avoid all that,” she said.

It was unclear if Perry, who has been in discussions with the DOT since April, will continue to pursue the dispensations.

But the deadline for new parties to join the federal lawsuit is Aug. 15, not Aug. 25, as the commissioners discussed, leaving the city only days to win any concessions from the DOT in return for not joining the suit.