A 62-year-old Holmes Beach man accused of stealing underwear is seeking the dismissal of the case in Manatee County Circuit Court.
Ernest A. Kendler, who has pleaded not guilty to a burglary charge, was arrested after law enforcement officers searched his residence and found pairs of women’s panties identified as belonging to a 23-year-old neighbor who reported them stolen in November, according to a police report.
Through Bradenton attorney Mark Lipinski, Kendler is questioning the constitutionality of the case, claiming that the prosecution’s filings are “legally vague, indistinct and uncertain.”
“The information read together with the probable cause affidavit in this action strongly suggests that more than one burglary is alleged,” the motion stated, adding that such results in “duplicity” and violates the state constitution.
If a judge declines to dismiss the case, Lipinski requested that the court order the state to provide more particulars about its case: the exact dates the home was burglarized, the exact criminal offense alleged to take place, the exact property taken during each burglary.
“Currently it is impossible for the defendant to prepare a defense,” the motion stated. “The information as currently charged exposes him to double jeopardy and negates a defense of alibi.”
The warrant that led to a search of Kendler’s property said a woman told the Holmes Beach Police Department she was missing two dozen pairs of panties and that her 21-year-old sister was missing 16 pairs of underwear.
The woman also said that on Nov. 6, 2010, she saw a man going through a dresser drawer in her sister’s bedroom, according to the warrant. The intruder did not face the woman, even as he left, but she said she believed the man to be Kendler.
In other court filings in the case, the prosecution submitted its potential witness list, which includes several Holmes Beach residents and three HBPD officers.
Potential evidence includes witness affidavits, police documents, lab reports, a criminal history, marijuana alleged to belong to Kendler, two pairs of underwear, plastic bags, a tin, a CD case and a drawstring bag.








