Stop Little Bo Peepin’ and start sheepin’
Little Bo Peep has found her sheep and they have black and white vertical stripes. The sheepshead bite around Anna Maria Island waters has fired up with good reports coming in from shore fishers as well as boaters.
The local fishing piers on the Island are a great spot to target these tasty crustacean-eating fish. With a multitude of pilings and barnacles, the sheepshead swarm to these piers to stage up and spawn.
A number of baits work for sheepshead. The most popular are fiddler crabs, sand fleas, oyster crabs and, of course, the undeniably best bait for sheepies, the tubeworm. The fiddlers and sand fleas are pretty easy to collect and if you don’t want to get your own purchase frozen ones at any of the local tackle shops. Tubeworms, on the other hand, require a little work. They might be the best bait, but they are the hardest to get. When fishing the nearshore reefs, you can catch sheepies on shrimp. What’s nice about shrimp is they are readily available, inexpensive and usually work.
Tackle for sheepshead fishing usually consists of a stout rod spooled with 15-pound line. A No. 4 or No. 2 size J-hook works well since the bait used is usually small. When choosing hooks, pick a strong hook that will not bend when you try to remove it from the sheepshead’s boney mouth. Sinker (lead) selection is determined by the location you’re fishing. If there’s a lot of current, use more lead. For leader, use 20-pound fluorocarbon.
Remember, there is a size limit on sheepshead. They have to be 12 inches long with the tail pinched. You can keep 15 per day. But if you’ve ever filleted sheepshead, you know that is more than enough to feed a family, not to mention a lot of work. Sheepshead have thick scales and a big rib cage, which will have you sharpening your fillet knife more than once throughout the process of cleaning a limit of fish.
All in all, the reward of having sheepshead for dinner is worth all the work. Until next week, tight lines.
Kim Shearer of Annie’s Bait and Tackle is reporting Spanish mackerel are showing up everywhere and Gotcha lures are the ticket for catching them. Some nice sheepshead up to 18 inches, were caught around the buoy in front of Cannons Marina on live shrimp, and mangrove snapper have been caught off of the Cortez Bridge. Capt. Mark Johnston of Legend Charters is reporting good results with sheepshead and Spanish mackerel.
Jonny Keyes at Island Discount Tackle says beach-action for whiting and shark is still going strong. Fishers targeting whiting are using fresh or frozen peeled-and-cut shrimp. “Small pieces of peeled shrimp on a No. 4 hook works great,” Keyes says.
Beach fishers are catching small black tip sharks as well as bonnethead sharks. “A 3- to 4-inch strip of squid is a good bet when targeting these smaller sharks,” Keyes says. Keyes recommends using a 1/0 long-shank hook with a wire leader for success in landing thee sharp-toothed scavengers.
Around the piers, passes and all through the Intracoastal Waterway, fishers targeting Spanish mackerel are still catching limits daily. Keyes says that the Gotcha plugs have still been the most-prized lure to catch Spanish mackerel. Other lures working well have been Clark spoons and white crappie jigs.
Sheepshead are making a good showing on docks and nearshore reefs. Keyes says fishers using frozen sand fleas and fiddler crabs are producing nice catches. “One day the sheepies are hitting fleas,” Keyes says, “and the next day they want fiddlers.”
Capt. Steve Salgado of the Compleat Angler fishing charters says the trout bite in Sarasota Bay is “on fire.” “We’re catching a lot of slot-size trout while fishing some of the deeper pot holes in the bay using live shrimp.” Salgado is also catching Spanish mackerel in the 24-inch range. Redfish is still abundant in the bay and Salgado is catching them in numbers using live shrimp fished on the bottom.
Capt. Warren Girle is fishing north Sarasota Bay targeting Spanish mackerel and spotted sea trout. “The trout and mackerel are everywhere on the flats,” Girle says.
An average of 50 to 70 trout are coming into the boat. “A lot of them are small, but we’re still managing to come back to the dock with our limit,” Girle added.
Shrimp fished under a popping cork is a good bet to target spotted sea trout. Since the Spanish mackerel are patrolling the same flats, expect your catch to be mixed.
Dock fishing for Girle is proving prosperous for redfish. Fish up to 25 inches are being caught on live shrimp fished under deepwater docks. Girle is also catching nice flounder in these same areas.
Bob Kilb at the Rod & Reel Pier says there are plenty of sheepshead being reeled up. Sand fleas, fiddlers and tubeworms are the producers for these buck-toothed fish. Spanish mackerel are making a showing at the pier too, although you have to be there at the opportune moment to catch them.
Since there are no big schools of bait around the pier, the mackerel are being caught while passing by. Once the bait is around the pier, the mackerel should be more consistent. And fishers targeting sheepshead are occasionally bringing up a black drum.
Capt. Wayne Genthner of Wolfmouth Charters says he’s catching Spanish mackerel on the artificial reefs in Sarasota Bay. Fish up to 25 inches are being caught on live shrimp. Trout fishing for Genthner is heating up with fish up to 21 inches coming to the boat. Live shrimp under a cork is a good offering. “If the bite is really good, I like to use tandem jigs and catch two trout at a time,” Genthner says.
While fishing the backwater creeks, Genthner is doing well targeting catch-and-release snook. Fish in the 30-inch range have been hitting select shrimp.
Moving offshore, Genthner says the gag grouper bite is still going strong. We can’t get down past the grouper to catch the mangrove snapper,” he says.
Capt. Mark Howard of SumoTime Fishing Charters says fishing this past week has been excellent. As the moon moves from new towards full, the sheephead bite will peak, providing for some “unbelievable fish catching opportunities.”
On Howard’s recent charters he’s been culling and releasing sheephead under 3 pounds. “Sheephead weighing 6 pounds have been landed with regularity,” Howard says.
Fresh shrimp rigged with a 2/0 hook and enough weight to get it to the bottom has resulted in some of the season’s best action.
Speckled trout have made a good showing over the grass flats of Anna Maria Sound with a popping cork and live shrimp combo worked aggressively to make a “chug” sound. A jig rigged with a soft plastic will also work with a popping cork combo.
Howard reports pilchards and greenbacks are slowly making their way into Tampa Bay and on the flats. “After the cold front blows through and the warmup begins, the bait should show up in force around their springtime spots,” Howard says.
Spanish mackerel are around with increasing numbers and they’re active on the drop-offs near the flats. Kingfish and cobia will soon make an appearance on the nearshore reefs as they follow the bait schools up the coast.
Send fishing reports to fish@islander.org.









