The May 19 ballot question:

“Shall William Shearon be removed from the office of mayor by recall?” Immediately following the question there shall be printed on the ballot the two propositions for Bradenton Beach voters:

X     “William Shearon should be removed from office.”

X     “William Shearon should not be removed from office.”

The questions will be followed by the balloting to fill the remaining term of mayor through November 2015 with the choice being between the two qualified candidates: Jack Clarke or William Shearon. If Shearon is removed, the highest vote-getter will take office. The choice is moot if Shearon is not recalled.

 

Do we have a race? Statute muddies mayoral election

By Ed Scott

Islander Reporter

Mayor Bill Shearon and Vice Mayor Jack Clarke qualified for the mayoral election that takes effect if Shearon fails to win the recall balloting.

The candidates for mayor appear on the same ballot as the recall to compete to succeed Shearon for the remainder of his term — which ends in November.

However, a law that requires Clarke to resign before running against Shearon initially raised questions about Clarke’s path to qualifying and demonstrated just how confusing conducting elections can be.

The matter started simply enough. The Committee to Recall William Shearon garnered the necessary signatures to recall the mayor. Acting on a brief from city attorney Ricinda Perry, Andrew Owens, chief judge of the 12th Judicial Circuit Court, set the recall election for May 19 and the qualifying period for April 14-17.

Timing was a delicate issue, as the election had to fit into a 30-60 day window, according to Florida Statute 100.361.

But questions were raised after Owens set the dates. While one section of F.S. 99.012, the so-called “resign-to-run” law, mandates that elected officials resign before running for another office, another section of that statute states that in order to retain office until either the election date or a successor is chosen, the written resignation must be submitted at least 10 days before the first day of qualifying.

On April 9, after Owens set the election and qualifying dates, Clarke submitted his resignation, stating it would be effective after the recall election.

To qualify based on the statute and the qualifying period, Clarke would have had to resign earlier, on or before April 4, 10 days before qualifying began. But that date falls before the supervisor of elections office verified the petition and before Owens’ April 9 order for the election.

Spokesman Dennis Menendez of Owens’ office wrote in an email regarding the situation: “The Court set the qualifying and recall election dates. Once the dates are set, any questions regarding these dates need to be addressed to the supervisor of elections.”

Manatee County Assistant Supervisor of Elections Scott Farrington said it’s not the purview of the supervisor to consider when a candidate resigns.

“The strictest of answers is that to qualify, the resignation has nothing to do with it,” Farrington said.

“The statute actually specifically states what’s required to qualify and the resignation is not in that particular section of the statute, so as a qualifying office, I would not even look for the resignation.” Farrington added, however, “That does not remove the requirement to resign.”

In such matters, city and county officials often turn to the state for guidance. In this case, the Florida Division of Elections deferred to the court.

Gary Holland, assistant director at the division of elections, said in an email that an elected official seeking another office “must comply with the law or else risk subsection 99.012 (5) of the law becoming applicable — that a court, upon a proper complaint being filed, rules that the candidate is not qualified and his or her name would not appear on the ballot.”

Holland provided case law as an example of the narrow ruling by the court in upholding the 10-day qualifying.

For his part, Clarke said he doesn’t know anything about the 10-day requirement. “I went down for qualifying, did what they told me to do and I am qualified,” he said.

Perry said in an email that it’s her opinion Clarke has substantially complied with the statute. When lawmakers enacted the resign-to-run statute in 1970, she said, “they were clear that the purpose for the 10 day notice was to advise the public of the seat that will now be open.

“At no point will Jack Clarke hold two offices at the same time and, more importantly, in that there is no special election to fill Ward 1 — the commission will be making an appointment for the seat (if Clarke is elected) — the purpose of the 10 days is of no effect.”

Shearon responded, saying everyone needs to play by the rules, “but it seems like we abide by some rules and not by others. That’s why I feel no matter which way this election goes, it’s going to be challenged.”